Question:
what does it mean to be free?
killermuldooogan
2006-02-09 09:14:58 UTC
what does it mean to be free? is a bird free just because it can fly, or is it still confined by the world by the universe so on. is there absolute freedom? hell, are there any absolutes. i imagine people will say death and taxes, but that's not good enough. i am completely without any kind of certainty; give me some.
Twenty answers:
Barthes
2006-02-09 11:34:05 UTC
There are so many different definitions of freedom that there can't be a nice, prepackaged pill to swallow that will help you understand this notion. I, personally, vascillate between existentialist "absolute freedom" and poststructuralist "contingency". Allow me to explain.



Sartre's notion is that each of us are utterly free, so much so that he actually suggests that we are condemned to freedom. (Hidden in this is, of course, the notion that humans don't actually want to be free, that the correspionding responsibility is wholly overwhelming.)



The problem here is that, quite simply, there is always a context. Metaphorically, the tree grows from soil, right? Many poststructuralist thinkers (Foucault, Lacan, etc.) would suggest that our identities are wholly contigent upon our environments, that our context "calls us into being". In this sense, then, freedom is a notion that comes after our identities, and is thus severely limited.



Obviously, these two perspectives are wholly in conflict, which is why I vascillate. I would suggest, ultimately, that absolute freedom exists independently of identity, that one must lose oneself before becoming free. Thus, freedom is not only something we cannot possess, but also something we cannot understand.



Okay, I'm done. Have a cookie, it always makes me feel better.
Bryna
2016-02-04 02:16:40 UTC
This Site Might Help You.



RE:

what does it mean to be free?

what does it mean to be free? is a bird free just because it can fly, or is it still confined by the world by the universe so on. is there absolute freedom? hell, are there any absolutes. i imagine people will say death and taxes, but that's not good enough. i am completely without any kind of...
Georgetta
2015-08-11 19:50:28 UTC
This Site Might Help You.



RE:

what does it mean to be free?

what does it mean to be free? is a bird free just because it can fly, or is it still confined by the world by the universe so on. is there absolute freedom? hell, are there any absolutes. i imagine people will say death and taxes, but that's not good enough. i am completely without any kind of...
bubblyandbright
2006-02-09 09:24:08 UTC
I'm going to have a try on this one; it's just what I think.



Well, there isn't really any definition of freedom. Some may think that freedom is the ability to do things at their own will, without being forced or compromised in any way. But then again, aren't we all guarded by the laws of the countries, and restricted in some kind of way?



I make some reference to psychologist B.F. Skinner, who tried to create a utopian world whereby everyone is being 'conditioned' to suit the political regime and environment of the nation an individual is in (as illustrated by his rather famous book Walden II). Critics began to bombard his ideas, saying that there is no freedom in a society where people are confined and conditioned to be a certain kind of person that the ruling party wants them to be, but yet he states, in Beyond Freedom and Dignity, that it is only when people are acting the way they should be that they can experience freedom.



Then again, in the modern world, there isn't really any complete freedom, which isn't such a bad thing after all. It may make some people feel like a caged bird, but heck. Imagine a world with total freedom - without being ruled or governed by the laws of the country (like in Golding's film Lord of the Flies) - they might be chaos, on the basis that humans are not innately responsible and behave like barbarians without proper civilisation.



Ultimately, I think what it means to be free is to be able to exercise our rights, without it being violated, and yet to be able to compromise in times when needed.
confucius sez
2006-02-10 01:44:51 UTC
Absolute freedom is an absolute impossibility. We all adhere to certain laws. Some of which simply cannot be broken, i.e. the laws of gravity, or centrivical motion. Being free would be to simply not want to break these laws. If every thing that I wanted to do was allowable within the laws of man and nature then I would be a free man.
Onion?
2006-02-10 00:30:17 UTC
To be free is to be able to say 2+2=4 or 2+2=5 without anyone trying to tell you otherwise. It's the ability to choose your own fate and the right to not be attacked by others because of what you do, think, look like, say, etc. Freedom is having your own mind and the ability to use with no one there to supress it. Freedom is impossible.
Fairenhight
2006-02-09 11:18:49 UTC
When we are born into this world we are given absolute freedom. If god exists, he dosn't breath down our necks telling us what we should be doing or what our purpose is. We are free. It is only through these virtual rules of society that we have built around ourselves that make us think we are not free. We already have the freedom. We only need the eyes to see it.
sfangelsfangel
2006-02-09 12:48:48 UTC
There is a certain freedom which is the freedom of the mind and For my part I think that we are like prisoners who do not realise they are prisoners, a simple example in our society it is considered normal to say good morning in the morning and to perform rituals like hand shaking so in doing so because everyone does it you already loose some part of your freedom just like me you've fallen in the trap of conformity . Answering your questions with a defined vocabulary is a sort of boundary to my freedom and everyones freedom as I 'm using what schools, education etc have imposed me, why not writing heylo instead of hello it's only because we abide to codes that make us loose our freedom.
laurieanne72
2006-02-09 09:20:40 UTC
To me, to be free means I am able to make my own decisions about my life without interference from anyone else.
2006-02-09 09:16:28 UTC
Jesus said, "Whom the Son sets free is free indeed."



Even though I am under state and federal taxes, bound to the earth and more, I am totally free because Christ has unloosed me from the bonds of sin and death. How much more free can you get than that? The rest is just annoyances.
juston k
2014-11-20 12:19:39 UTC
True freedom is not being able to do what every you want to do when every you want to do it. That is slavery to your own desires. But yet true freedom is slavery. It's being a slave to Christ and serving Him out of love.
magicman
2006-02-09 09:18:31 UTC
No really knows what it is to be free because true freedom is an illusion.
cydomph
2006-02-09 09:24:11 UTC
free means you can do whatever it is that you want to do at your own will, and pay for the consequences later =P
david333221
2006-02-09 19:36:34 UTC
It means that you don't have to do bad things.
2006-02-10 04:59:46 UTC
i am free!

thats why they call me a freak!

freedom can fly and see!

if you see you can fly high into the dark!

and wonder stevie!

wonder!
wolfstarzz
2006-02-09 09:20:59 UTC
It means chaos.
pomosimulacrum
2006-02-09 09:20:07 UTC
"Freedom is just another word for 'nothing left to lose'"
2014-09-30 22:38:19 UTC
The poem invictus.
davidmp
2006-02-10 04:58:57 UTC
"suicide is the ultimate kind of freedom" SENNECA.
2006-02-09 09:16:23 UTC
Uh wtf.



go to school for 20 years, you're still dumb, get a job for 40 years, retired, end. repeat


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...